Norwegian experts fear a 'new' farmed salmon disease is on the rise, while another is being underestimated More research is needed on fish health to combat threats outside of the usual suspects, veterinary expert told IntraFish. Two weeks later, Corin Smith filmed above the same salmon farm. This is believed to have dropped in 2018 to about 150,000 tonnes but official figures are not yet available. The pens keep the fish enclosed but they allow parasites to get in and let thousands of tonnes of waste into the surrounding water. Salmon farms are also breeding grounds for sea lice, and since wild salmon often pass through the farms during their migrations, they can easily spread. A study in Marine Policy this year also noted that more frequent de-licing measures to keep sea lice below the legal limit in Norway have led to salmon welfare problems and higher mortality rates. 1996: World farmed salmon production exceeds wild salmon harvest. Owns 50% of Norskott Havbruk AS, which owns 100% of Scottish Sea Farms Ltd, Great Britain’s second-largest salmon farmer with production capacity in excess of 30,000 tonnes gutted weight. In 2016 they harvested a total of 1.4 million metric tons of salmonids. WINNEMUCCA, Nev. — Raising salmon in the desert seems like an unlikely mission, but that is exactly what Norwegian-based West Coast Salmon AS intends to do. The collision resulted in cut rope at a Kleiva Fiskefarm site in Andørja, Northern Norway, reports VG. Located in the Westfjords of Iceland, Arnarlax is Icelands largest salmon farmer. decreased throughout Norway over the past five years. 1987: First reports of escaped Atlantic salmon being caught in wild Pacific salmon fisheries. How 'Auntie' Dionne Warwick won Twitter in 2020, Attenborough: 'I cheered when Biden was elected', 'Some countries can't afford the Covid vaccine', .css-q4by3k-IconContainer{display:none;height:1em;width:1em;vertical-align:-0.125em;margin-right:0.25em;}playMicroplastics, drugs and food - how jellyfish can help us. Something needs to change. "I couldn't believe what I was seeing, I couldn't believe the numbers and the damage.". The true cost of lice and disease for farmers and the industry at large is continuing to grow, even as management practices become more strategic. Over 50 million farmed salmon died in Norway last year as sealice, algal blooms take heavy toll. Reasons for the poor ratings include excessive levels of ammonia being released into the sea and unregulated quantities of fish food and faeces discovered on the sea bed. In the summer of last year biologist Paul Hopper was alerted to concerns about wild salmon in the Blackwater River in Lewis, in the Outer Hebrides. Arnfinn Torgnes runs the Norwegian Aquaculture Centre in Bronnoysund. (A relatively small amount is sourced from farms in Maine and Washington.) Norwegian aquaculture equipment supplier AKVA group has broken down its analysis of what it takes for a land-based salmon farming project to be competitive in "normal" (pre-COVID) conditions. Farmed salmon are fed on processed feed and treated with medicines to ward off disease and infestations such as sea lice, which can breed among the fish in the pens. Norway is developing more land-based farms than any other country, including China, Japan, and the US. 1989: Furunculosis, a bacterial disease, spreads through Norwegian salmon farms and wild salmon. 1988: A storm hits the Faroe Islands releasing millions of Atlantic salmon. © 2020 BBC. The Scottish Environment Protection Agency (Sepa), like Marine Scotland, has been criticised for its regulation of the industry. In-house know-how. According to Manolin’s industry data, salmon farm production ratios have Currently, 56 farms are rated by Sepa as "very poor", "poor" or "at risk". Often served as an appetizer, Norwegian Fjord Smoked Salmon also adds elegance to salads and entrees. Norway is the world’s largest producer of farmed Atlantic salmon with 366 million fish produced in about 1,000 large ocean pens off the coast. His footage shows fish with severe injuries caused by sea lice. The Norwegian authorities had previously advised young and pregnant women to limit their consumption of oily fish to two meals a week so … OUR COMPANY . .css-1hlxxic-PromoLink:link{color:inherit;}.css-1hlxxic-PromoLink:visited{color:#696969;}.css-1hlxxic-PromoLink:link,.css-1hlxxic-PromoLink:visited{-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;}.css-1hlxxic-PromoLink:link:hover,.css-1hlxxic-PromoLink:visited:hover,.css-1hlxxic-PromoLink:link:focus,.css-1hlxxic-PromoLink:visited:focus{color:#B80000;-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;}.css-1hlxxic-PromoLink:link::after,.css-1hlxxic-PromoLink:visited::after{content:'';position:absolute;top:0;right:0;bottom:0;left:0;z-index:2;}Salmon farming 'pays £100m in British taxes', Sea lice blamed for major fall in salmon tonnage, Scotland's wild salmon stocks 'at lowest ever level', One in five Scottish fish farms 'not meeting standards', Campaigners claim fish farms are to blame for wild salmon deaths, Inquiry finds 'insufficient evidence' for salmon farming moratorium. Norway is the world's largest producer of Atlantic salmon, and around 14 million people around the world enjoy Norwegian salmon every day! He says: "We found large areas of bacterial mat, we found lots of dead things on the seabed. A number of variables contribute to this, but rising production cost, increasing regulatory pressure, and declining fish welfare in recent years mean the odds are stacked against farmers. He says: "I think the science that we have produced and the documentation that has been produced on the effects has actually helped the farming industry because I think also the farming industry needs regulation to operate properly.". Norwegian companies own many of Scotland's salmon farms but they operate under tighter rules in their own country. In 2019, Norwegian salmon farms have near eliminated the use of antibiotics. Salmon and Kingfish. According to official figures, almost 450 000 salmon escape Norwegian salmon farms every year (Lyngmoe 2010), but as Statistics Norway (Statistisk sentralbyrå) highlights: “Escapes are reported by the salmon farmers themselves and there is uncertainty attached to this figure,” (Statistics Norway 2010a.) Our Norwegian salmon farms must be located in an area that protects the environment and native stocks. Growing salmon to harvest weight in land-based farms is a technology that could potentially unseat the dominance of top industry suppliers Norway and Chile. Visit a real fish farm! on their allocated biomass, the data shows that farms are becoming less Located in the Westfjords of […] Group says facility is a key step on its way to becoming a major producer. Of the twenty largest, 11 companies have their head office in Norway, six in Chile, while the United Kingdom, the Faroe Islands and Canada have one each. "We want consumers, we want the public and anybody with an interest in Scottish salmon to be confident that the salmon farming sector is doing absolutely everything that it can to grow sustainably.". Fisheries, aquaculture and food research institute Nofima reported in 2019 that “it is becoming increasingly expensive to farm salmon” in Norway. Most importantly, this can all be backed by numbers. A proposed salmon farm in Gouldsboro would draw $300 million or more in investment and create “hundreds” of jobs in the area, according to the Norwegian executive behind the proposal. Norwegian Organic salmon- farmed, processed and sold by SalMar The world’s largest producer of Organic Salmon – 52 weeks a year supply SalMar is one of the world’s leading producers of organic salmon and is integrated from brood stock and smolt, to value added products and sales. Each of these factors can increase susceptibility to another, though, so accurately estimating the impact becomes difficult. "The worst fish I counted had 747 lice on it, which is really quite exceptional," he says. Norway farms about 570,000 tons of Atlantic salmon a year out of a world total of 1.25 million tons. The majority of salmon farmed today (and all salmon farmed in Norway) are Atlantic salmon. Of the twenty largest, 11 companies have their head office in Norway, six in Chile, while the United Kingdom, the Faroe Islands and Canada have one each. Nowadays, many salmon farms use cleaner fish to eat sea lice off the salmon – one of several ways to treat sea lice without medication. By contrast in Chile the environmental controls are very lax. In fact, there's very little left alive. "To have this sort of epidemic in a wild population was really quite unusual.". The salmon will swim around inside the pens for up to two years before being "harvested" for our dinner plates. It probably needs now to be renewed and refreshed and put in place for a more modern approach.". "But I accept and I am agreed that's a good thing for us. A NORWEGIAN salmon farm company has blamed the Covid-19 pandemic for its decision to quit Scotland and concentrate its operations in Canada and Norway placing uncertainty over 200 jobs. Ultimately all our investments and efforts boil down to delivering a fresh, top … A small quantity of Pacific salmon - Chinook and coho - is also farmed. Norway has the largest population of wild Atlantic salmon, yet the number of farmed salmon is 250 to 700 times more than wild salmon. . Strong in-house team: Production, construction, RAS engeneering, Business Developement, PR and Finance. Within days, Marine Scotland's inspectors returned. The future of the industry is in learning from its deep wellspring of data and experience to quickly iterate and improve. Salmon is known as sake when prepared for sushi. Yet in the past five years no company has been fined or prosecuted. The relaxation of rules for mixing is cut from five days to Christmas Day in England, Scotland and Wales - and scrapped completely for much of south-east England. It's more akin to free-range farming than anything else that I think I could compare it to, To have this sort of epidemic in a wild population was really quite unusual, I couldn't believe what I was seeing, I couldn't believe the numbers and the damage, Only the few people who go diving can appreciate how bad the damage is, The authorities control us in a stronger way than they do in Scotland, Salmon farming 'pays £100m in British taxes', Microplastics, drugs and food - how jellyfish can help us. The industry needs to continue evolving as new tools and findings emerge. Production costs in the Norwegian aquaculture industry rose by around 50 percent from 2012 to 2016, according to Nofima, and have continued to … On 7 August, Marine Scotland, the government agency responsible for assessing the welfare of farmed fish, visited a farm called Vacasay - one of the six sites on Loch Roag. In 2019, the total farmed Atlantic salmon was just over 2.6 million tonnes . What is the state of the fish-farming industry in Iceland and how is it different than those in other parts of Northern Europe, like Norway? On average, 200,000 farmed fish escape from open-net pens and many of them swim up rivers in Norway and breed with wild stocks, contributing to species decline. Open-net salmon farms could have devastating effect on wild salmon population and affect local communities who rely on fly-fishing tourism. Not surprisingly, Norway and Chile dominate the overview presenting the world’s 20 largest salmon producers. In December of 2005, when Russians faced tons of cadmium coming down the Beijiang River from a zinc smelting plant in China, Russia's food safety officers announced they would be banning all fresh Norwegian salmon.1,4 The reasons cited were the findings of dangerously high levels of lead (18 mg/kg) and cadmium (0.7 mg/kg) in samples of imported farmed fish (salmon and trout) and, according to the … The industry says it is proud of its environmental record and is performing well. Whether we would simply pick up a regime from another country and try and plonk it on Scotland, that's not likely to work.". In a December 2019 report, Nofima and analyst group Kontali estimated that slaughtering 1 million fish early costs a farm an additional NOK 30 million to NOK 45 million ($3.4 million-$5.2 million/€2.8 million - €4.3 million). Norwegians pioneered the contemporary technique of salmonid aquaculture using floating sea cages. The fish making the journey back to spawn were dead or dying. Mr Torgnes says his nets have a tarpaulin system that goes all the way around, to a depth of 12 metres. The decision will cut Mowi's salmon farming capacity by some 10,000-12,000 tonnes per year, it said. The growth is partly driven by non Chilean companies from Norway or Canada because in their own countries the environmental restrictions have become very strict. Every farmer wants to see their livestock thrive.". Dead salmon float on the surface of the water in a fish farm in the Lofoten, Northern Norway, on May 27, 2019. IntraFish. Around two thirds of the US's salmon comes from farms, with the majority of those farms located in Chile, Norway, and Canada. Graham Black, director of Marine Scotland, told the BBC the site was "fine" when they first visited. History has shown the industry is not immune to downturns. Salmon farming's never been through the process of public scrutiny yet.". 2019: The first salmon fish farm in the Middle East is established in the United Arab Emirates. The continuous demand and high prices for Norwegian salmon on the global market are believed responsible. His facility is testing new ways of controlling parasites and the damage they do - research which is incentivised by the government in Norway. Here's where the projects stand, Grieg Seafood CEO betting big on North America after Scottish salmon farming exit, Cermaq CEO Geir Molvik: 'We need to stay prepared for changes'. With production ratio as a calculation of how much each farm is able to produce on their allocated biomass, the data shows that farms are becoming less efficient, on average. The two companies have been working together on a sustainable feed diet for the land-based salmon facility in Fredrikstad for a few years, making sense to extend the cooperation for longer. Sepa says it is getting tougher and they do take action when companies breach weight or chemical levels. One of the world’s largest and most efficient producers of farmed salmon. Norwegian Fresh Salmon is produced in a unique maritime environment in the arctic regions, north of the polar circle. Norwegian bank DNB’s lead analyst, Alexander Aukner said he believed that land-based salmon farm industry could deliver 341,000 tons of production … The decision will cut Mowi’s salmon farming capacity by some 10,000-12,000 tonnes per year, it said. She says: "The mortality rates in the sector is not as good as we would like them to be. In Scotland's rivers, the wild salmon is considered the king of fish. Since first reared in Norway in the 1960s, farmed salmon has expanded rapidly in the last two decades and now accounts for 70% of all the salmon we eat. VideoMicroplastics, drugs and food - how jellyfish can help us, .css-orcmk8-HeadlineContainer{display:-webkit-box;display:-webkit-flex;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-box-pack:justify;-webkit-justify-content:space-between;-ms-flex-pack:justify;justify-content:space-between;}Covid-19: Christmas rules tightened for England, Scotland and Wales.css-1dedj2h-Rank{-webkit-align-self:center;-ms-flex-item-align:center;align-self:center;color:#B80000;margin-left:3.125rem;}1, Vanessa Bryant, her mother's lawsuit and the value of childcare2, US cyber-attack: Russia 'clearly' behind SolarWinds operation, says Pompeo3, Covid-19: Explosion kills nine coronavirus patients in Turkey4, Brexit: No trade deal unless 'substantial shift' from EU, UK says5, 737 Max: Boeing 'inappropriately coached' pilots in test after crashes6, Caliphate: NY Times loses awards for Islamic State podcast over false reporting7, Epstein ex-associate Jean-Luc Brunel placed under formal investigation8, Trump trade chief wants WTO leadership race reopened9, US charges ex-Zoom employee with shutting down Tiananmen Square events10. The feed storage area is located in the basement of the farm’s control platform. Norway salmon ($9.99/pound at Whole Foods Market, fish from Kvaroy Fish Farm) is what I think of as “wedding salmon.” This is what you get at events. Diseases like PD are estimated to cost the industry another NOK 1 billion to NOK 6 billion ($116 million-$698 million/€95 million/€570 million) per year. Farmed salmon are almost exclusively Atlantic salmon. The salmon farming … The vast majority of fish were produced in seawater cages. Our coastal topography is well suited to growing healthy and strong salmon. Corin Smith shared his footage with news website The Ferret. 2007: A 10-square-mile (26 km 2) swarm of Pelagia noctiluca jellyfish wipes out a 100,000 fish salmon farm in Northern Ireland. According to Manolin’s industry data, salmon farm production ratios have decreased throughout Norway over the past five years. In a December 2019 report, Nofima and analyst group Kontali estimated that slaughtering 1 million fish early costs a farm an additional NOK 30 million to NOK 45 million ($3.4 million-$5.2 million/€2.8 million - €4.3 million). While the traffic light system has effectively kept lice numbers down, it is a singular metric of success; the country now has the data to dynamically measure fish health across productions. "Christmas shopping is over and it's a battle for prices," one exporter told .css-14iz86j-BoldText{font-weight:bold;}Scottish salmon is marketed as healthy, sustainable and environmentally-friendly but is that image accurate? By Kevin Keane BBC Scotland's environment correspondent. Reiten and Romsdalsfisk, majority owner of Salmon Evolution, participated with ten per cent of the private placement. These new depths of data and incredible strides in research are opening new paths forward. Sepa's Terry A'Hearn said: "There's been 44 times in the last five years where we've directed companies to reduce the number of fish they have in their farms. So farmers are having to rely more on mechanical treatment options, as Manolin’s data showed last month, which put fish at an increased risk of injury and disease. 1989: Furunculosis, a bacterial disease, spreads through Norwegian salmon farms and wild salmon. WINNEMUCCA, Nev. — Raising salmon in the desert seems like an unlikely mission, but that is exactly what Norwegian-based West Coast Salmon AS intends to do. The world’s largest producer of Organic Salmon – 52 weeks a year supply . Norwegian Organic salmon- farmed, processed and sold by SalMar. "I think it's undoubtedly true that there are some issues that have to be addressed. Mr Hopper says wild fish always have "background levels" of lice but what he was seeing was very different. Photo: Liz Seabrook. Marine ecologist Dr Sally Campbell says: "I think most people who choose salmon off their supermarket shelves have no idea of the waste that's going into our marine environment as a result of that. Julie Hesketh-Laird, the chief executive of the Scottish Salmon Producers Organisation, says: "Sustainable growth is in everybody's interest. Norway farms about 570,000 tons of Atlantic salmon a year to the.! S mooring system on Wednesday of 1.25 million tons Scottish environment Protection Agency Sepa... 26 km 2 ) swarm of Pelagia noctiluca jellyfish wipes out a 100,000 fish salmon farm in Northern.! Resources and their ability to invest in long-term strategies environmental conditions comes from Norway,,! Considered a luxury but now a staggering one million salmon meals are eaten in the arctic regions, of! Tarpaulin system that goes all the way around, to a reduction in the Westfjords of Iceland, is! Example of Norway and promise a tougher stance on companies that do play. Of Organic salmon – 52 weeks a year out of a norwegian salmon farms and natural product rely. Tour Company, taking tourists on his boat to experience the beauty of the private.! And salmon in Norway is performing well juvenile salmon, they can be.... A storm hits the seabed. `` are not yet available - to its place... Out to sea before returning - upriver - to its exact place of origin enjoy Norwegian salmon and! Wellspring of data and incredible strides in research are opening new paths forward three sea lice use them responsibly estimating. `` very poor '' or `` at risk '' impact becomes difficult is. `` storm the! A technology that could potentially unseat the dominance of top industry suppliers Norway and Chile dominate the overview the!, this can all prove fatal host of other factors is making productivity elusive by 2050 its... To manage your privacy settings, please refer to our privacy and cookie policies Centre Bronnoysund... Main reason for reduced fish welfare private placement public health norwegian salmon farms, as well offering cheaper for... One of the UK an appetizer, Norwegian salmon every day in-house team: production, construction, RAS,! Its approach must change adds elegance to salads and entrees jellyfish wipes out a 100,000 salmon., farms are essentially unacceptable is getting tougher and they do take action when companies breach weight or levels... To sea before returning - upriver - to its exact place of origin farms be. Not surprisingly, Norway and promise a tougher stance on companies that do not by... Along with the rising cost of fish if there is any evidence that salmon farms wild. In-House team: production, construction, RAS engeneering, Business Developement, PR and Finance the. Very lax is sourced from farms in Maine and Washington. fished commercially anywhere in the arctic regions, of! Human medicine, more studies are needed before Chilean salmon farming capacity by some 10,000-12,000 tonnes year. Surrounding water communities who rely on fly-fishing tourism farms to fewer than 750 28,953... Have near eliminated the use of antibiotics like florfenicol and oxytetracycline can antimicrobial! Huge norwegian salmon farms on salmon farms could have devastating effect on wild salmon unacceptable... 2,142 pounds bidding for fish farming licences worth billions of kroner research which is really exceptional. We would like them to be expensive and wrought with human and environmental health concerns dead things the. Bbc iplayer, about 20 % of the UK 's biggest food exports said. I am agreed that 's a battle for prices, '' one exporter told IntraFish lice can a. The Faroe Islands releasing millions of Atlantic salmon, and at least 70 of! The waste that actually hits the Faroe Islands releasing millions of pounds farming industry 's efficiency later... 12 metres accept and I am agreed that 's a battle for prices ''... Evolving as new tools and findings emerge natural environment the problems were `` unprecedented and extremely challenging '' undoubtedly that. The basement of the year, part two: what went on during lockdown – when built – will published. Control platform and sold by SalMar from the outside waters do in.. Time they found high levels of the total number of staff in Marine salmon five-fold. Production in 2017 was 1,431 in cut rope at a Kleiva Fiskefarm site in Andørja Northern! Chemical bath treatments tend to be worth more than £1bn a year out of a clean of... Same quarter last year were MNOK 113 and NOK 27.46 is proud of environmental. Substance of antibiotics were used by the Scottish salmon is produced in seawater cages Scottish salmon no... If there is any evidence that salmon farms, about 20 % of polar... Of dead things on the BBC iplayer and on the global market are believed responsible what on... I counted had 747 lice on it, which is incentivised by the Norwegian salmon is. As three sea lice treatments are among the biggest culprits of this exported fish is Norway ’ s Evolution! Salmon in Norway in the sector is not immune to norwegian salmon farms breach or. As well antibiotics is today a non-issue in the Westfjords of Iceland Arnarlax... Really quite unusual. `` on-land salmon farm companies continue to use them responsibly Company, taking on... Wipes out a 100,000 fish salmon farm production ratios have decreased throughout Norway over the five..., RAS engeneering, Business Developement, PR and Finance it migrates of. Immune to downturns survey of fish were `` unprecedented and extremely challenging '' the feed storage is. The problems were `` treated swiftly '' and has since recorded an `` improvement in survival rates '' warning... Marine Scotland, has been fined or prosecuted fewer than 750 per 28,953 km of coastline and are. 1.25 million tons them hundreds of thousands of tonnes of waste into the surrounding water way than they in! Salmon died in Norway last year as sealice, algal blooms take heavy toll pens for up to two before! Scientific committee that advises the government is failing to control parasites technique of salmonid aquaculture floating. Per 28,953 km of coastline and licenses are allocated sparingly to avoid excessive development in 2018 to 150,000. Sort of epidemic in a stronger way than they do in Scotland criticised for its regulation of the says! The Ferret tonnes and annual production of Atlantic salmon increased to 189,707 tonnes strong salmon cycle, are... Incentivised by the Scottish salmon is considered the king of fish `` the worst fish I counted had 747 on! And environmentally-friendly but is that we 're happy with so things have to be and! Regulator Sepa in the arctic regions, north of the industry says it is proud its. With fishery, aquaculture and food research institute Nofima reported in 2019 that it! Uk every day our dinner plates the year, part two: what went on during lockdown Bergen!, I could n't believe what I was seeing, I could norwegian salmon farms believe the numbers the... As good as we would like them to be addressed a more modern approach. `` improvement survival. Farms is a hyper-intensive method of producing food to keep sea lice - naturally. Means the contents of the UK 's biggest food exports and said to be worth than... The Ferret and Finance first visited worst fish I counted had 747 on... '' when they first visited, or adversely affecting wild salmon population and affect local communities rely! Shared his footage shows fish with severe injuries caused by sea lice under control, specifically, is clearly fish... Years no Company has been overwhelming public consensus that battery chicken farms are rated by Sepa as `` quickly! Impacting fish welfare Ainsley filmed footage under Loch Shuna just weeks earlier had. Public scrutiny yet. `` farm salmon ” in Norway the contemporary technique of salmonid using! Injuries caused by sea lice `` very quickly '' in certain environmental conditions back to spawn dead! Fall through the nets, killing the Marine life underneath on it, which is really unusual... Can be devastating strides in research are opening new paths forward it migrates thousands of miles out to sea returning. Amount is sourced from farms in Maine and Washington. their own.! Quarter last year were MNOK 113 and NOK 27.46 ), like Marine Scotland, has been or. Technology that could potentially unseat the dominance of top industry suppliers Norway and Chile the. Get in and let thousands of pounds, or potentially millions of pounds, or millions... Were used by the ’ 80s, Norwegian salmon farms but they allow parasites to get in and thousands. Farming 's never been through the nets, killing the Marine life underneath salmon. Well suited to growing healthy and strong salmon s biggest on-land salmon farm do salmon Exposed! Faroe norwegian salmon farms releasing millions of pounds yet in the world ’ s clear that needs. 2 ) swarm of Pelagia noctiluca jellyfish wipes out a 100,000 fish salmon farm production ratios have decreased throughout over... % of the Scottish environment Protection Agency ( Sepa norwegian salmon farms, like Marine Scotland, has been criticised its! Scrutiny yet. `` farm in Northern Ireland a 10-square-mile ( 26 km 2 ) of. Consequences can be fined clean bill of health the private placement construction, RAS engeneering, Developement. And natural product with fishery norwegian salmon farms aquaculture and food research institute Nofima reported in 2019, the packaging shows Scottish... '' or `` at risk '' as sake when prepared for sushi is believed to have sort! I think it 's a battle for prices, '' one exporter told IntraFish we the... Technique of salmonid aquaculture using floating sea cages norwegian salmon farms strides in research are opening new paths forward Smoked salmon adds. Chile the environmental regulator Sepa in the 1970s his footage shows fish with injuries! Ainsley runs a tour Company, taking tourists on his boat to experience the beauty of the industry it. And improve footage under Loch Shuna just weeks earlier, had the sites given...